When Lindsay Clancy’s treating psychiatrist took the stand and insisted that her patient never reported hearing voices or experiencing psycH๏τic symptoms, the defense was waiting with a sealed set of records that had never crossed the doctor’s desk. Dr. Jennifer Tufts maintained that throughout fourteen telehealth appointments spanning September 2022 to January 23 2023 she observed only anxiety, adjustment disorder with depressed mood, and occasional pᴀssive suicidal ideation that Clancy herself described as something she feared might develop rather than something already present.

The final session, conducted less than a day before the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan, produced notes describing a woman who claimed she was managing and had no active plans. Then attorney Kevin Reddington produced the Aspire crisis-line logs showing two separate calls in December in which Clancy sought help and was told she did not meet criteria for inpatient care because she lacked a specific plan. Tufts acknowledged under oath that she had never been informed of those contacts and that she had not asked about them.

The courtroom reaction was immediate; several jurors leaned forward as the implications settled. Additional testimony revealed that Clancy’s five-day stay at McLean Hospital in early January likewise contained no documentation of command hallucinations or frank psychosis. Prosecution experts later seized on the absence of any contemporaneous report of voices before the incident itself, calling the sudden appearance of a male voice commanding the killings “very unusual.” Defense experts, including filicide specialist Dr. Phillip Resnick, argued that the very nature of postpartum psychosis can produce rapid, discrete episodes that leave no earlier paper trail. The file the psychiatrist never saw has therefore become more than a single piece of evidence; it is a symbol of every communication gap, every short virtual session, and every missed opportunity that the defense claims allowed a treatable condition to reach its irreversible endpoint.

Source: https://nypost.com/2026/08/05/us-news/lindsay-clancy-sobs-as-nanny-describes-slain-son-callan-3-as-happiest-sweetest-easiest-baby/