Susan Smith Faces Second Parole Hearing 32 Years After Drowning Her Two Young Sons; Ex-Husband Demands She Remain Imprisoned for Life

  • November 19, 2026

Susan Smith, the South Carolina mother who deliberately drowned her two young sons more than three decades ago, is scheduled to appear before the state parole board for a second time. Her former husband, David Smith, has made clear he will again oppose any release and wants her to remain behind bars until the end of her life.

In October 1994, 23-year-old Susan Smith drove her car into John D. Long Lake in Union County with her sons — 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex — still strapped in their car seats. The boys drowned as the vehicle sank. Smith initially told police that a Black man had carjacked her at a traffic light and driven away with the children. The story triggered a mᴀssive search and national media attention. Nine days later, she confessed that she had staged the crime herself.

Prosecutors argued that Smith killed the boys in an attempt to pursue a relationship with a married man who had told her he did not want children. A jury convicted her of murder in 1995 and sentenced her to life in prison. Under the law in effect at the time, she became eligible for parole after serving 30 years. Her first parole bid was unanimously denied in November 2024.

Now 55 and held at Leath Correctional Insтιтution, Smith is set for another hearing on Thursday, November 19, 2026. In her previous appearance before the board, she described her actions as “horrible,” said she had become a Christian, and asked the panel to show the same mercy she believes God has shown her.

David Smith, 56, has remained firmly opposed to her release. In recent interviews he said the pain of losing his sons still feels as raw as it did 32 years ago. “Thirty-two years hasn’t changed the heartache,” he told CNN. He rejects any suggestion that the killings were a tragic mistake, insisting that Smith deliberately ended the children’s lives and has never expressed genuine remorse to him. “If I have a choice, I’d want her to stay in prison until she dies,” he stated.

David Smith plans to attend the hearing, accompanied by his current wife and other family members, and will urge the board to deny parole. He has said he does not want to hear anything further from Susan and that any decision to free her would represent an injustice to Michael and Alex. He also expressed concern that, while many people believe the board will reject her again, there is no guarantee.

Under South Carolina rules, Smith needs the support of two-thirds of the seven-member parole board to be released. Historical data show the board grants parole in only a small percentage of cases, particularly those involving violent crimes. Even so, David Smith has made clear he will continue to fight every attempt she makes for freedom as long as he is able.

The case remains one of the most notorious child murder cases in modern American history, and the upcoming hearing has once again brought national attention to the lasting impact on the surviving family members.