SUMMER WELLS: A NEW SEARCH ON VAN HILL ROAD RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT THE MISSING TENNESSEE GIRL

ROGERSVILLE, Tenn. (WSMV) – “One of the most extensive missing child investigations” in Tennessee’s history has reached its five-year mark, and despite thousands of tips, the case has continued to stump investigators.

Summer Wells was just 5 years old when she was reported missing from her Hawkins County home on June 15, 2021. The blonde-haired, blue-eyed girl weighed approximately 40 lbs. at the time and was about 3 feet tall.

Since her disappearance, officials say they have pursued multiple leads in the case. An AMBER Alert, which remains active, disseminated her case onto cell phones and TV sets nationwide. Dozens of agencies spanning multiple states, including Ohio, Virginia, Georgia and North Carolina, also joined in the search.

Investigators are still searching for Summer Wells, five years after the then-6-year-old girl...
Investigators are still searching for Summer Wells, five years after the then-6-year-old girl went missing from her Hawkins County home. This age-progressed image, released in August 2025, shows how Summer would likely look at the age of 9. (TBI)

After half a decade of investigation, here’s where her case stands.

But even with hundreds of thousands of eyes on the lookout, no arrests have been made, and Summer has not been found.

The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation called the case “outside of the norm,” noting that “there are few clues as to what happened to Summer despite investigators doing everything within their power to find answers.”

“While there are no new developments to announce publicly, the investigation remains active and ongoing,” the TBI said in a social media post Monday. “Every credible lead continues to be evaluated, and our determination to find the truth has not changed.”

Summer’s parents also acknowledged the significant date.

“This is a tender and quiet week for us. Candus and I would like to thank each person who cares about our daughter Summer,” her father wrote Sunday on the Find Summer Wells Facebook page. “Your kindness and prayers mean a lot.”

“Even the smallest detail could make all the difference in this case,” said TBI Director David Rausch.

Family describes last sighting of Summer
Summer was last seen by her family at their home on Ben Hill Road in the Beech Creek Community of Rogersville, a mountainous town north of Greeneville in East Tennessee.

According to findsummerwells.com, a website launched by her family in the wake of her 2021 disappearance, the then-5-year-old was last seen heading downstairs to the home’s basement. The family noted that the basement had a door facing the back of the house.

Her family was home, upstairs and in the front of the house at the time.

“Chaos panic fear broke loose,” a blog post from her parents said of the day the girl went missing.

She was last seen wearing a pink shirt and grey shorts or pants, and she may have been barefoot at the time.

A picture of Summer Wells from a Prayer Vigil.
A picture of Summer Wells from a Prayer Vigil.(WVLT)

Authorities ask for information about red truck

Since Summer was last seen, the TBI has released a description of a vehicle that could be important to the case.

Agents said they have been unable to track down a red Toyota Tacoma with a full-bed ladder rack and white buckets in the bed.

“An individual who travels through the area regularly as part of his job stated that he recalls possibly seeing a 1998-2000 maroon or red Toyota Tacoma, with a full bed ladder rack and white buckets in the truck bed. The individual stated that the truck might have been parked in the area of Beech Creek Road and Ben Hill Road in the late afternoon to early evening on either Monday, June 14th, or Tuesday, June 15th,” the TBI says. “…Our hope was that the individual might have information that could help the investigation. The driver has not come forward, nor have the hundreds of vehicles reported to us as matching the description panned out.”

Conflicting theories surface in wake of girl’s disappearance
A year after Summer’s disappearance, her father, Don Wells, released a letter to who he described as his daughter’s kidnappers. The statement was released from the Hawkins County Jail, where Wells was behind bars on unrelated charges.

However, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation has contradicted the girl’s family, saying there is no evidence indicating Summer was abducted from her family home.

The TBI said their teams conducted “three large-scale ground searches” and multiple targeted searches in the first year of its investigation.

Investigators worked thousands of hours on the case, per the state agency, interviewing family, neighbors and registered Sєx offenders in the area as part of their work on the case. They analyzed cell phone data, served search warrants, scoured social media, “diligently working to find answers.”

One spot searched multiple times by police and volunteers was Beech Creek, an area near Summer’s home described as one of law enforcement’s “areas of interest.”

“This investigation weighs heavily on us all, and I promise that no one wants answers more than we do,” TBI representative Leslie Earhart said in a 2022 press conference.

Latest development
Last November, agents with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation stirred up new hope in Summer’s case.

A new lead to law enforcement to the 3500 block of Van Hill Road, a remote area north of Baileyton. The two-lane road winds through a hilly wooded area, following Gardner Creek and Patterson Branch stream.

It’s flanked with houses breaking up the otherwise dense wood line.

However, law enforcement did not release further details on what they found in that area, which is about 9.8 miles from Summer’s family home on Ben Hill Road in Rogersville.

Investigations into Summer’s parents
Summer’s parents have faced scrutiny in the years since her disappearance.

When asked if Summer’s parents were suspects, TBI officials said they had not ruled out any possibility.

Hawkins County officials later revealed Don Wells had been arrested on domestic ᴀssault charges the year before his daughter was last seen. Additionally, Summer’s mother, Candus Bly, filed for an order of protection against the father. In the now dismissed order of protection, Bly said “I am afraid for my children and myself.”

Bly alleged at the time that Don Wells was mentally and physically abusive. However, the mother later asked for a dismissal of the order of protection. On April 21, 2021, the charges of domestic ᴀssault and unlawful possession of a weapon were also dismissed.

Six months after those charges were dropped, Don Wells was arrested for driving under the influence. The 56-year-old was charged that October with driving under the influence, open container, expired registration, improper lane usage and violation of financial responsibility, according to a Hawkins County record-keeping app Mobile Patrol.

In February of 2022, Don Wells pleaded guilty to DUI. It was his first DUI, but since the arrest violated previous probation, he was sentenced to 11 months and 29 days at the Hawkins County Jail.

He has since been released.

See this interview from 2023 with Don Wells:

Summer’s parents have also publicly reported that the Tennessee Department of Child Services removed their three sons from their home in July of 2021, although the details on their removal are murky and the parents’ statements have been limited and inconsistent.

Don Wells told the Kingsport Times News in the weeks following his daughter’s disappearance that the Tennessee Department of Children’s Services had removed Summer’s three brothers from his and Bly’s care.

At the time, he declined to speak with WSMV’s sister station WVLT about the development, saying he wouldn’t speak on whether DCS had removed his children.

But Bly and Don Wells have since written in blog posts saying that DCS took the boys “hundreds of miles away” from their home “with parental permission to protect them from the chaos.”

In June of 2025, the couple shared in a blog post that the “State of Tennessee has the three Boys,” although they denied any wrongdoing and said they were cleared in two state investigations.

Don shared two documents online, showing the order of dismissal with a caption saying, in part, “all opinions of abuse or neglect are dropped and unsubstantiated by judge order.”

“DCS said we weren’t bad then; We aren’t bad now,” a joint blog post from the couple said.

Cases involving minors are protected and not publicly accessible, so WSMV4 cannot independently confirm their statements.

As of June 2026, it is unclear if the three boys have been returned to their parents.

Copyright 2026 WSMV. All rights reserved.