PART 3: THE MAN UNDER THE FLOORBOARDS KNEW THE TRUTH ABOUT SARAH

PART 3: THE MAN UNDER THE FLOORBOARDS KNEW THE TRUTH ABOUT SARAH

Rowan pulled Mara away from the window.

“Get down!”

He carried Eli from the cradle and moved both infants behind the heavy stone fireplace.

Another gunsH๏τ struck the cabin wall.

Mara covered Lily with her coat.

“Rowan, listen to me.”

“Not now.”

“You have to listen!”

She pointed toward the floor.

Three knocks sounded again.

Then a fourth.

Rowan stared at the wooden boards beneath the kitchen table.

He knew every inch of that cabin.

He had built most of it with his own hands.

There was no cellar beneath the kitchen.

At least, there hadn’t been when Sarah was alive.

“Who is down there?” he whispered.

Mara shook her head.

“I don’t know. Silas told me that if I ever reached a cabin with a blackened chimney and a broken pine tree beside the gate, I should look beneath the floor.”

Rowan felt the blood drain from his face.

His cabin had both.

The chimney had been damaged by lightning the previous spring.

And the pine tree beside the gate had been split during a windstorm.

“Why didn’t you tell me sooner?”

“Because I didn’t know whether I could trust you.”

Another knock.

This time, a voice followed.

“Rowan?”

He nearly dropped the rifle.

He knew that voice.

It belonged to Samuel Pike, his closest neighbor and the man who had helped bury Sarah three days earlier.

“Sam?”

“Open the door, son!”

Rowan approached cautiously.

Mara grabbed his sleeve.

“Don’t.”

“He’s my neighbor.”

“That’s what I was afraid of.”

Rowan looked at her.

“Why?”

Mara swallowed.

“Silas said Crowe had a man inside every settlement. Someone who could report which families had received supplies, who had money, and who lived alone.”

The voice outside grew louder.

“Rowan! I saw the tracks. I know you’ve got company.”

Rowan didn’t move.

“Sam, why are you here?”

“Because I’ve got something important to tell you.”

“What?”

A pause.

Then Samuel answered.

“Your wife wasn’t supposed to die.”

The words seemed to freeze the entire room.

Rowan’s rifle lowered slightly.

“What did you say?”

“I said Sarah’s death wasn’t natural.”

Mara closed her eyes.

Rowan stepped toward the door.

“Explain yourself.”

“Open up first.”

“No.”

Silence.

Then Samuel sighed.

“Fine. I’ll tell you through the door. That woman inside your cabin is dangerous, Rowan. She’s connected to a man who has been robbing this territory for years.”

Rowan glanced at Mara.

She was trembling.

But it wasn’t fear for herself.

It was fear for him.

“Who is Crowe?” Rowan demanded.

Samuel laughed softly.

“Now you’re asking the right question.”

A moment later, the footsteps retreated.

Rowan waited until the sound disappeared into the snow.

Then he turned toward Mara.

“Tell me everything.”

She looked at the floor.

“Silas wasn’t only a freight clerk. He was a bookkeeper. He discovered that Crowe had been collecting money from ranchers for supplies and selling those same supplies elsewhere.”

“How much money?”

“Thousands of dollars.”

Rowan shook his head.

“Why would Sarah be involved?”

Mara looked at him.

“Because she discovered something, too.”

Rowan felt his heart pound.

“What?”

“Your wife was helping Silas.”

The room became painfully quiet.

“No,” Rowan whispered.

Mara reached inside Lily’s blanket and removed a small folded piece of paper.

“Silas wrote this before he disappeared. He said Sarah had found the missing records and hidden them somewhere Crowe would never think to look.”

Rowan stared at the handwriting.

He recognized the name at the bottom.

Silas Callaway.

“Why would Sarah help a stranger?”

“Because she believed those stolen supplies belonged to families who needed them. She told Silas that if the truth could save even one family from losing their home, it was worth the risk.”

Rowan remembered something.

Two weeks before Sarah died, she had begun spending evenings in the pantry.

She had told him she was organizing old preserves.

He had thought nothing of it.

Now he wondered what else she had been doing.

The knocking beneath the floor returned.

Rowan took a lantern and moved the kitchen table aside.

One of the boards near the wall seemed slightly different from the others.

He pressed it.

Nothing happened.

Then he noticed a small iron ring hidden beneath a woven rug.

He pulled.

The board lifted.

Cold air rose from the darkness below.

A narrow wooden ladder descended into a small underground room.

Rowan looked at Mara.

“Stay here.”

She shook her head.

“I’m coming.”

“You’re injured.”

“And you don’t know what you’re looking for.”

He wanted to argue, but she was already standing.

Together, they descended.

The space below was barely large enough for two people. There were shelves along the walls, a wooden trunk, and several old lanterns.

But what caught Rowan’s attention was the pH๏τograph resting on a small table.

Sarah.

Standing beside a younger Samuel Pike.

And between them was a man Rowan had never seen before.

Mara picked up the pH๏τograph.

“That’s Silas.”

Rowan turned it over.

Three words had been written on the back in Sarah’s handwriting.

Trust the blue thread.

He looked at Mara.

“What does that mean?”

Mara carefully examined the old trunk.

Its lid was locked.

There was no keyhole, only a small piece of blue thread tied around one corner.

She touched it.

Then she noticed the sтιтching along the underside of Lily’s blanket.

The same blue thread.

Mara’s eyes widened.

“Silas made this blanket.”

She carefully opened a hidden seam.

Inside was a tiny brᴀss key.

Rowan stared at it.

“Your husband put a key inside your daughter’s blanket?”

“He told me that if we were ever separated, Lily would carry something that could bring the truth to light.”

Mara inserted the key.

The trunk opened.

Inside were several documents, a leather-bound ledger, and a small envelope addressed to Sarah Blackthorne.

Rowan’s hands began to shake.

He opened the envelope.

The letter was dated twelve days before Sarah’s death.

Dear Sarah,

If this reaches you, then Crowe knows what we’ve discovered.

You were right about Samuel. He has been giving him information about the ranches, the families, and the deliveries. But there is something worse.

Crowe has been using the names of ᴅᴇᴀᴅ people to collect payments. One of those names is your husband’s.

Rowan stopped reading.

His own name.

He read the next line.

Rowan Blackthorne has been listed as the owner of a freight shipment he never received. If Crowe’s men come looking, they will claim Rowan owes them money. They intend to take his ranch as payment.

Rowan felt sick.

The cabin.

The land.

Everything he and Sarah had built.

Someone had been trying to steal it.

And Sarah had known.

He continued.

Please tell Rowan the truth when the time is right. I am afraid Crowe has someone watching your house. I don’t know whom to trust anymore.

There is one more thing.

If anything happens to me, do not let them convince Rowan that it was an accident.

The letter slipped from his fingers.

He remembered Sarah’s final night.

The doctor had arrived late.

Samuel had been the one who brought him.

Samuel had insisted on staying until the birth was finished.

And afterward, he had told Rowan that Sarah’s death was simply one of those tragedies that sometimes happened.

Rowan had believed him.

Now every memory seemed to have a shadow.

A sudden cry came from upstairs.

Eli.

Rowan rushed up the ladder.

Mara followed as quickly as her injured shoulder allowed.

They found Eli awake in the cradle, crying weakly. Lily was beside him, her little face turned toward him.

Mara lifted her daughter.

“Something’s wrong.”

Rowan checked Eli.

His skin felt unusually warm.

Panic rose in his chest.

“No. No, not him.”

Mara examined the baby and immediately looked toward the fireplace.

“The room is too cold at night, and he hasn’t been eating properly. We need someone experienced with newborns.”

“I can’t leave the cabin.”

“Then we need someone to come here.”

Rowan looked toward the window.

The storm had almost stopped.

Iron Ridge was several miles away.

He could ride there if the road was clear.

But he couldn’t leave Mara alone with the men searching for her.

As if the thought had summoned them, a horse whinnied outside.

Then another.

Three riders appeared at the edge of the clearing.

The first was Samuel Pike.

The second was a tall man wearing a black wool coat.

The third carried a wooden box.

Mara recognized the tall man immediately.

Her face turned white.

“That’s Everett Crowe.”

Rowan moved toward the window.

Crowe dismounted and removed his gloves.

He looked directly at the cabin.

Then he raised one hand.

Not in greeting.

In warning.

Samuel stepped forward and called out.

“Blackthorne! We know what’s beneath your floor.”

Rowan’s blood ran cold.

Crowe smiled.

“And we know what your wife left behind.”

He reached inside his coat and pulled out a folded document.

“Your ranch is no longer yours, Mr. Blackthorne.”

Rowan stared at the paper.

Crowe continued.

“According to this agreement, your late wife signed the property over to my company three days before she died.”

Rowan felt as though the ground had disappeared beneath him.

Sarah’s signature was at the bottom.

It looked real.

But he knew his wife.

He knew how she wrote her name.

And there was one detail Crowe had overlooked.

Sarah always placed a tiny star beside her final letter.

There was no star on this document.

Rowan slowly raised his eyes.

“That’s a forgery.”

Crowe’s smile disappeared.

Then the tall man looked past Rowan, directly toward the fireplace.

“I see you’ve found the children.”

Mara pulled Lily closer.

Crowe took one step toward the porch.

“Give me the ledger, the letter, and the girl. Do that, and I’ll let you keep your cabin.”

Rowan’s grip тιԍнтened.

“You’re not taking anyone from this house.”

Crowe looked at him for a long moment.

Then he said something that made Rowan’s entire world collapse.

“Ask your neighbor what happened to your wife, Blackthorne. He was the last man who saw her alive.”

Samuel looked down.

And from behind Crowe, a fourth rider slowly emerged from the trees.

He was thin, pale, and leaning heavily against the saddle.

Mara stopped breathing.

“Silas?”

The man lifted his head.

His eyes found his wife.

Then they moved toward Lily.

“Don’t give them the ledger,” he rasped.

“Because the man who killed Sarah…”

He pointed directly at Samuel Pike.

“…wasn’t working for Crowe alone.”

And the next name in the ledger was the one Rowan least expected to see.