đ âHE RAN TOWARD THE CHAOS⌠AND INSTANTLY KNEW THE TRUTHâ â A Coachâs Emotional Testimony Is Breaking Hearts Across America

The coach of a Texas high school jock that was allegedly stabbed to death by Karmelo Anthony sobbed as he recalled realizing the teen âwas goneâ just moments after the knifing.
Victim Austin Metcalfâs family was brought to tears as Frisco track and football coach Robert Starr recounted seeing a âcommotionâ at the Kuykendall Stadium on April 2, 2025, and going over to where the 17-year-old was on the ground, NBC 5 reported.
âHis face is purple, and he has a big hole in his chest,â Starr testified at the first day of the murder trial against Anthony.
Metcalfâs family openly cried in the gallery of the Collin County courthouse in McKinney as Starr spoke.
Anthony, now 19, is accused of stabbing Metcalf in the chest with a foldable knife over a dispute that began after Metcalf asked Anthony to move out from under his teamâs tent.
Starr began to sob as he described going over to where trainers were trying to revive Metcalf before Metcalfâs twin, Hunter, pleaded with Starr to âdo something,â as he pointed toward Anthony.
Starr went over to where Anthony was â but others told the upset coach to leave.
When Starr returned to Metcalf, everyone was praying and Starr and Hunter got on their knees and also prayed, he recalled.
âI just knew Austin was gone,â the coach said.
The next day, Starr sent a text to Metcalf saying, âI love you man. Sorry I didnât say enough,â according to exhibits shown to the jury.
Mecalfâs dad, Jeff, wiped his eyes as the messages were shown.
The incident unfolded after Austin, a student at Frisco Memorial High School, told Anthony, who attended Frisco Centennial High School, to move away from their team area.
The pair allegedly shoved each other before Anthony stabbed Metcalf, a move he claims he made in self-defense.
Starr told the jury that heâd tasked Anthony â who was a discus and sHŕšĎ put thrower, as well as a football player â and a few other teammates with leading that day, which meant setting up the tent and moving equipment.
The coach explained that the tent âmarks your spotâ and said you donât go under other teamâs tents.
Athletic trainer Tiffany Whiteaker took the stand next, telling the jury about performing CPR while her partner did chest compressions until medics arrived.
Once he was given a transfusion, some color returned to Metcalfâs face which Whiteaker said gave her false hope â which was dispelled after she saw his chest wound.
Vincent Hooper, a coach from another school, told jurors next about holding Anthony to ensure he didnât leave.
Hooper said Anthony told him, âHe put his hands on me. I stabbed him.â
âYou know, if he dies, youâve changed your whole life,â Hooper said, according to a report by the Daily Mail.
The then 17-year-old didnât believe Metcalf was going to die, Hooper recalled.
âHeâs not going to die,â Hooper said Anthony told him.
âBut if he doesâŚâ Hooper replied, prompting Anthony to start crying, he recalled.
Despite not knowing each other, the pair hugged, Hooper said.
The coach then called over Anthonyâs coaches, he said.
Hooper also testified he had to stop another of Austinâs teammate from attacking Anthony.
During opening statements, Anthonyâs lawyer, Mike Howard, told the jury that a much larger Metcalf started the dispute with Anthony and that the knifing was purely to protect himself.
âWhatâs important to know is Melo is 5 foot 8 and 140 pounds. Hunter and Austin Metcalf are 6 foot 1 about 80 pounds heavier than Melo,â Howard claimed.
Anthony âremained seated, even when Austin and Hunter stood up,â the defense attorney said.
âIt is uncontroverted that Austin makes the first physical contact. Austin grabs, punches, pushes. In that split second, Melo has a decision to make â how and when to act,â the defense attorney said.
But prosecutor Bill Wirskye told the jurors in his opening statements that Anthony carried out the âsenselessâ crime before ditching the knife and trying to flee the stadium.
âIf youâre scared and running away in self-defense, why toss the knife?â Wirskye said.
Anthony has pleaded not guilty. He faces up to life in prison if convicted.





