PART 2 — THE SECRET BEHIND THE EMPTY CHAIR

PART 2 — THE SECRET BEHIND THE EMPTY CHAIR
“Good pie?” Edith asked again.
Coulter looked down at the golden slice.
“The best.”
“Then I hope mine doesn’t disappoint her memory.”
He glanced at Edith, surprised by the answer.
For a moment, the kitchen was quiet except for the crackling stove.
Then Coulter picked up his fork and took a bite.
His expression changed.
“That’s close.”
“Close?”
“My mother used cinnamon.”
“So do I.”
“She added a little nutmeg.”
Edith raised an eyebrow.
“Then perhaps you should have mentioned that before I baked it.”
A faint smile appeared beneath his mustache.
“Perhaps I should have.”
It was the first time Edith had heard him speak about his mother without immediately ending the conversation.
She poured herself some tea.
“Was she a good cook?”
“She could feed thirty men with a sack of potatoes and make them believe they’d eaten like kings.”
Edith smiled.
“Sounds like a woman I’d have liked to meet.”
Coulter’s smile disappeared.
“She would have liked you.”
Edith looked down at her cup.
She wanted to ask more, but something in his voice warned her that the subject carried old sorrow.
Instead, she changed the subject.
“Your men are eating twice as much as they did when I arrived.”
“They’re working harder.”
“They’re also stealing biscuits.”
“That’s Jed.”
“I know. I caught him yesterday.”
“What did you do?”
“Made him wash the baking trays.”
Coulter chuckled.
“Sounds like justice.”
Edith laughed too.
And for a few precious minutes, the ranch kitchen felt less like a workplace and more like a home.
But the peace did not last.
The following morning, Edith found a stranger standing beside the pantry.
He was a narrow-faced man in a gray coat, with polished boots that seemed entirely unsuitable for ranch work.
“Miss Mayburn?”
“Yes?”
“My name is Silas Vane. I represent the Powder Creek Mercantile Company.”
Edith wiped her hands on her apron.
“What can I do for you?”
He placed a folded paper on the table.
“Mr. Grady has an outstanding account with our company. Payment is overdue.”
Edith glanced at the paper.
The amount was substantial.
Far more than she expected for flour, coffee, sugar, and ordinary supplies.
“Mr. Grady handles the accounts.”
“Of course. But I was told you manage the kitchen purchases.”
“I order food. I don’t manage the ranch finances.”
Vane smiled without warmth.
“Then perhaps you can explain why the food orders have increased so dramatically since your arrival.”
Edith looked at him.
“Twenty-one men eat three meals a day.”
“Twenty-one men did not require so much food before.”
“They were hungry before.”
The merchant’s smile vanished.
“Be careful, Miss Mayburn. A cook should not concern herself with matters beyond her position.”
Edith folded the paper and handed it back.
“And a merchant should not charge a ranch for goods he hasn’t delivered.”
For the first time, Vane looked genuinely unsettled.
“What did you say?”
Edith pointed to the list.
“You charged for twelve sacks of flour last month. I received eight. You charged for four barrels of apples. There were only two in the delivery wagon.”
“Your memory is mistaken.”
“I count every sack when it arrives.”
Vane snatched the paper.
“You would be wise to remember that you’re an employee here.”
“And you would be wise to remember that I can read.”
He left without another word.
Edith watched him ride away, wondering why a simple question about flour had made the man so angry.
She did not know that Coulter had been watching from the barn.
Nor did she know that Silas Vane had not come to collect money.
He had come to discover how much Edith had noticed.
That evening, Coulter entered the kitchen carrying a small ledger.
“Did Vane visit you?”
Edith looked up from the bread dough.
“Yes. He seems unhappy about the amount of food twenty-one men eat.”
Coulter placed the ledger on the table.
“He’s been unhappy about my accounts for months.”
Edith wiped her hands.
“May I see?”
Coulter hesitated.
Then he opened the book.
“Tell me what you think.”
Edith examined the pages.
The entries were neat, but something bothered her. Several deliveries had been charged twice. Other items had been listed at prices that changed from one week to the next.
She turned another page.
“Who signs for the supplies?”
“Usually Jed or Thomas.”
“And who pays the invoices?”
“I do.”
Edith tapped a line.
“Then why does this say you received twenty barrels of flour in October?”
Coulter frowned.
“Because that’s what the invoice says.”
“I received six.”
He stared at her.
“Six?”
“Six barrels. And two were damp.”
Coulter leaned over the book.
Edith continued turning pages.
“There are charges for coffee, sugar, and dried fruit that never arrived. And someone has been adding extra amounts to the monthly totals.”
“How much?”
She reached for a pencil.
“Let me calculate it.”
For nearly an hour, she worked in silence.
Coulter stood beside the table, watching her move through the figures with remarkable speed.
Finally, she put down the pencil.
“Mr. Grady, I believe someone has been stealing from you.”
He stared at the total.
Nearly three hundred dollars.
That was enough to purchase several horses or pay a ranch hand’s wages for months.
“Who?”
Edith shook her head.
“I don’t know. But whoever is doing it knows you rarely inspect the smaller purchases.”
Coulter looked at her.
“Why didn’t I notice this?”
“Because you were busy running a ranch.”
“And you noticed it because you cook?”
“No,” Edith replied quietly. “Because my father taught me to keep accounts before he died.”
Coulter looked surprised.
“You never told me that.”
“You never asked.”
He studied her for a moment.
Then he closed the ledger.
“From now on, I want you to help me check every supply invoice.”
Edith blinked.
“Mr. Grady, I’m your cook.”
“You’re also the sharpest pair of eyes I’ve got.”
She looked down, trying to hide her smile.
It was the first time anyone had trusted her with something beyond a stove, a needle, or a shopping basket.
And she intended to prove that trust deserved to be given.
Three days later, the ranch received an unexpected visitor.
A woman arrived in a black carriage.
She was elegant, perhaps thirty-five, with pale gloves, a fitted traveling coat, and a small feathered hat.
Coulter was repairing a fence when he saw the carriage.
His hammer stopped moving.
Edith noticed the change in his face from the kitchen window.
“Who is that?” she asked Jed.
The ranch hand suddenly became interested in his boots.
“Miss Caroline Bell.”
“An old friend?”
Jed scratched his jaw.
“Something like that.”
Caroline stepped out of the carriage and smiled when she saw Coulter.
“Coulter.”
He removed his hat.
“Caroline.”
“I heard you were back from the cattle buyers.”
“I’ve been home for weeks.”
“I would have visited sooner, but I was told you had taken on a new cook.”
Her eyes moved toward the kitchen.
“Apparently, quite an unusual one.”
Edith felt her stomach тιԍнтen.
Coulter’s expression hardened.
“What do you need, Caroline?”
The woman’s smile became smaller.
“Must I have a reason to visit an old friend?”
“You usually do.”
Caroline laughed softly.
Then she stepped closer.
“My father has been asking about you. He believes there may still be a way to settle the matter between our families.”
Coulter said nothing.
Edith turned away from the window.
She had no right to listen to a private conversation.
But she could hear Caroline’s next words clearly.
“Surely you haven’t forgotten what we promised each other.”
A long silence followed.
Then Coulter answered.
“That promise ended five years ago.”
Caroline’s expression changed.
“You ended it. I never agreed.”
She glanced toward the house again.
“Is this woman the reason?”
Coulter’s voice was cold.
“Leave Edith out of this.”
Caroline smiled.
“Edith?”
She repeated the name as though tasting something unpleasant.
“How quickly you have become familiar.”
Coulter stepped back.
“Your visit is over.”
Caroline’s smile disappeared.
“Think carefully, Coulter. My father still owns the note on your western pasture.”
For the first time, Edith understood.
Caroline had not come to rekindle an old romance.
She had come with a business threat.
And the ranch might be in more danger than anyone had told her.