PART 2 — THE HYMN THAT MADE THE STRANGER TURN PALE

PART 2 — THE HYMN THAT MADE THE STRANGER TURN PALE

Naomi stared at Wade.

For several seconds, neither of them moved.

Behind them, Effie continued singing.

Her little voice was soft and imperfect, rising and falling with the familiar melody she had carried in her memory for years.

Wade looked as though he had seen a ghost.

“Where did she learn that song?” he asked again.

Naomi’s hand тιԍнтened around the edge of her shawl.

“She doesn’t know.”

“That isn’t possible.”

“What isn’t?”

Wade turned toward the cave.

His face had lost every trace of warmth.

“Where did she get it?”

“I told you. She has sung it since I found her.”

“Found her where?”

Naomi frowned.

“On the switchback trail. Two summers ago.”

Wade looked back at her.

“Exactly where?”

“Near the old bridge.”

His breathing changed.

“You said she was alone?”

“Yes.”

“Was there a wagon?”

Naomi hesitated.

“There had been an accident. The wagon was already down the ravine.”

“Any bodies?”

“None that I could find.”

Wade closed his eyes.

Naomi’s suspicion sharpened.

“You know something.”

He didn’t answer.

“Mr. Sutton.”

Still nothing.

“Wade.”

He finally looked at her.

“Yes.”

“What do you know about Effie?”

His jaw тιԍнтened.

“I don’t know her.”

“Then why did that hymn frighten you?”

“It didn’t frighten me.”

“You look terrified.”

Wade glanced toward the cave.

“That song was sung by women in my mother’s family.”

Naomi’s heart skipped.

“What?”

“My grandmother taught it to my mother. My mother taught it to my sister.”

He swallowed.

“It was never written down. Nobody outside our family knew it.”

Naomi stared at him.

“That is impossible.”

“I know.”

Effie’s singing suddenly stopped.

The cave fell silent.

Then the girl appeared at the entrance.

“Why did you stop talking?”

Wade looked at her.

For a moment, he couldn’t speak.

Effie tilted her head.

“Mr. Sutton?”

Wade crouched slowly until he was at her eye level.

“Effie, who taught you that song?”

The girl frowned.

“I don’t remember.”

“Did someone sing it to you?”

She nodded.

“Who?”

“My mama.”

Wade’s face changed.

Naomi stepped forward.

“Effie has never mentioned a mother.”

The little girl touched the silver locket hanging around her neck.

“She said I must never open this.”

Wade stared at it.

His eyes widened.

“May I see that?”

Effie stepped backward.

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because Mama said bad people would come if they knew I had it.”

Wade slowly stood.

“Who was your mother?”

Effie looked confused.

“She was just Mama.”

Naomi’s heart тιԍнтened.

She had asked Effie those questions before.

The girl remembered almost nothing about her life before the accident.

But there had always been one thing she refused to discuss.

The locket.

Wade walked toward the fire.

“Naomi.”

She turned.

“Can I speak with you privately?”

They stepped outside.

The wind had died.

Snow covered the mountains like a white blanket.

Wade lowered his voice.

“I need you to listen carefully.”

Naomi folded her arms.

“I’m listening.”

“That girl may not be an orphan.”

“What?”

“I believe her mother was my sister.”

Naomi stared at him.

“You said your sister died.”

“She did.”

“When?”

“Three years ago.”

Naomi’s face went pale.

Three years.

The same year her husband died.

The same year she disappeared into the mountain.

The same year Effie appeared on the trail.

“What was her name?”

Wade looked toward the cave.

“Clara.”

Naomi whispered the name.

Effie had once said something strange while sleeping.

Clara.

Naomi had ᴀssumed it was part of a dream.

“You’re certain?”

Wade nodded.

“My sister disappeared with her daughter.”

“You never found them?”

“No.”

“Then how do you know Effie is your niece?”

“I don’t.”

He reached into his coat.

From an inner pocket, he removed an old pH๏τograph.

A young woman stood beside a little girl.

The girl was perhaps six years old.

She wore a silver locket.

Naomi’s breath caught.

The locket was identical.

But there was something else.

The child’s face.

It was Effie.

Older by only a few years.

Naomi’s hand went to her mouth.

“Where did you get this?”

“It was the last pH๏τograph my sister sent my mother.”

“Why didn’t you tell me when you arrived?”

“Because I didn’t know.”

“Until the hymn.”

“Yes.”

Naomi stared at the pH๏τograph.

“Why would your sister hide here?”

Wade’s expression darkened.

“She wasn’t hiding from the weather.”

“What was she hiding from?”

He looked toward the valley.

“A man named Silas Vane.”

Naomi knew the name.

Everyone in the territory did.

Silas Vane owned mines, freight contracts, and half the lawmen in three counties.

“He was searching for Clara?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

Wade’s eyes hardened.

“Because Clara stole something from him.”

“What?”

“A ledger.”

Naomi felt cold despite the fire.

“What kind of ledger?”

“One containing names.”

“Whose names?”

“Judges. Sheriffs. bankers. ranchers.”

He paused.

“And the names of men who paid Vane to make people disappear.”

Naomi stared at him.

“Clara was carrying that ledger?”

“Yes.”

“Where is it?”

Wade looked at her.

“I don’t know.”

Inside the cave, something crashed.

Naomi spun around.

“Effie!”

She ran inside.

The little girl stood beside the table.

The silver locket was open.

For the first time in two years, it had opened.

Naomi stared.

Inside was a tiny folded piece of paper.

Effie’s hands trembled.

“I didn’t do it.”

Naomi rushed to her.

“It’s all right.”

Wade entered behind her.

He saw the paper.

His face went white.

“Don’t touch it.”

But it was too late.

Naomi had already unfolded it.

Only six words were written there.

Wade Sutton knows where we are.

Everyone froze.

Wade slowly looked toward the cave entrance.

Outside, Bear began growling.

Then barking.

A horse whinnied in the snow.

Wade reached for his gun.

“How many men?” Naomi whispered.

He listened.

“Too many.”

A voice echoed from the darkness.

“Clara’s daughter!”

Effie screamed.

The voice came again.

“We know she’s in there.”

Wade looked at Naomi.

His expression was no longer that of a weary cattle drover.

It was the expression of a man preparing for war.

“Naomi,” he said quietly, “there’s something I didn’t tell you.”

“What?”

He pulled the hammer back on his revolver.

“I wasn’t separated from my cattle outfit.”

Naomi stared at him.

“I came here looking for Effie.”

Outside, another voice shouted.

“And we came looking for Wade.”

A gunsH๏τ exploded against the stone wall.

Wade grabbed Effie.

“Get down!”

Naomi dropped beside them as bullets tore through the cave entrance.

Then Wade whispered the words that changed everything.

“Those men aren’t here for the ledger.”

He looked at Effie’s frightened face.

“They’re here because they know she remembers where it is.”