PART 2 — “THE CHOICE WAS FINALLY HERS”

PART 2 — “THE CHOICE WAS FINALLY HERS”

Winnie stood in the lantern light for a long time.

No one had ever handed her a choice before.

People had handed her work and rules and an hour to pack.

They had never handed her the right to decide where she belonged.

She looked at Harlan.

“You would really let me stay?”

His expression barely changed.

“If you want to.”

“And if I leave?”

“I’ll take you to the stage.”

“You wouldn’t be angry?”

“No.”

“Even if I left because of the gossip?”

Harlan’s eyes softened.

“I’d be sorry.”

That was all.

No pleading.

No guilt.

No promise he could not keep.

And somehow, that made the decision harder.

Winnie looked toward the house.

Through the kitchen window, Tuck was sitting at the table with his tin whistle.

He was waiting for her.

She had never had anyone wait for her before.

“I’ll stay,” she whispered.

Harlan didn’t move.

“Are you certain?”

“No.”

He almost smiled.

“That’s an honest answer.”

Winnie looked up at him.

“But I’m certain I want to find out.”

Something changed in Harlan’s face.

He reached for her hand.

His fingers were rough from ranch work, but his touch was careful.

“Then we’ll find out together.”

The next morning, Winnie returned to the courthouse.

She brought every receipt from Pear Hollow.

Harlan carried the cigar box.

Tuck carried the tin whistle.

Mr. Grubb looked over his spectacles when they entered.

“I wondered when you’d come back.”

“You knew there was something wrong,” Winnie said.

“I suspected.”

He opened the county records.

For two hours, Winnie read.

She compared dates.

Names.

Signatures.

Parcel numbers.

Then she found it.

A small entry buried between two livestock liens.

“Mr. Grubb.”

He came closer.

“This creek claim was filed after the mortgage.”

“Yes.”

“But the bank couldn’t have purchased the water rights then.”

“Why not?”

“Because the original owner wasn’t the bank.”

Harlan leaned over the book.

“Who was it?”

Winnie traced the name with her finger.

“Edmund Vale.”

Harlan’s face changed.

“Vale?”

Mr. Grubb nodded slowly.

“Your wife’s father.”

Silence.

Winnie looked at Harlan.

“Beatrice’s father owned the creek rights?”

“He owned the orchard.”

“Not just the orchard.”

She turned another page.

“He owned the water.”

Harlan stared at the record.

“Then how did the bank get it?”

Mr. Grubb sighed.

“That’s the question.”

They found the answer in a deed filed eight years earlier.

Beatrice Vale had inherited the water rights.

After her death, they should have pᴀssed to her husband.

But the deed had been transferred six months later.

To the bank.

Harlan’s face went pale.

“I never signed this.”

Winnie looked closer.

“You didn’t have to.”

She pointed at the signature.

“This isn’t yours.”

Harlan leaned closer.

He couldn’t read the words, but he knew his own name.

“Someone forged it.”

Mr. Grubb closed the book.

“Now you understand why Mr. Stern wanted you gone.”

Winnie swallowed.

“He knew I could find this.”

“And he knows you found it.”

They left the courthouse in silence.

Outside, snow had begun to fall.

Harlan helped Winnie into the wagon.

Tuck climbed between them.

For several minutes, nobody spoke.

Then Tuck asked quietly:

“Does this mean we lose the ranch?”

Harlan looked at the boy.

“No.”

Winnie looked at him.

“You don’t know that.”

Harlan met her eyes.

“No.”

Then he smiled faintly.

“But I’m beginning to believe we might not.”

That evening, someone tried to break into the summer kitchen.

Harlan heard the noise first.

He grabbed his rifle.

Winnie followed him.

The door stood open.

Inside, drawers had been pulled out.

Old papers covered the floor.

Harlan’s expression hardened.

“They’re looking for something.”

Winnie crouched beside the fireplace.

“Not something.”

She picked up a loose floorboard.

“Something hidden.”

Underneath was a narrow tin box.

Harlan stared at it.

“That belonged to Beatrice.”

Winnie opened it.

Inside lay several letters.

The first was addressed to Harlan.

The second was addressed to Winnie.

She stared at her own name.

“I’ve never seen this.”

Harlan’s voice dropped.

“Neither have I.”

Winnie opened it with trembling fingers.

The handwriting was unfamiliar.

Miss Acterburg,

If you are reading this, then Mr. Stern has already tried to remove you from Pear Hollow.

Winnie’s breath caught.

The letter continued.

Do not trust the bank.

Do not trust the man who claims the water belongs to him.

And above all, do not believe that Beatrice died without knowing what was being done to her husband’s ranch.

Harlan stepped closer.

“What does that mean?”

Winnie turned the page.

There was only one final sentence.

The proof is beneath the pear tree she planted herself.

They looked at each other.

Outside, the orchard stood silent beneath the snow.

One tree had always been different from the others.

Beatrice’s pear tree.

Harlan had never let anyone touch it.

Winnie folded the letter.

“We have to dig.”

Harlan shook his head.

“Not tonight.”

“Why?”

He looked toward the dark window.

“Because whoever searched this room knows we found something.”

A horse whinnied outside.

Both of them froze.

Then came the sound of footsteps in the snow.

Someone was standing near the orchard.

Harlan raised his rifle.

“Stay behind me.”

Winnie reached for his sleeve.

“I’ve spent eleven years being told to stay behind someone.”

He looked at her.

“I’m not doing that anymore.”

Then she picked up the lantern.

“We find the truth together.”

Harlan stared at her for a moment.

Then he nodded.

Together, they stepped into the snow.

Neither noticed the shadow watching them from beyond the orchard fence.

The man held a lantern low.

And in his pocket was a letter bearing Beatrice Voss’s handwriting.