The Male Voice That Ordered Her to Strangle Three Children – Why Eleven Jurors Believed Lindsay Clancy’s Hallucinations and One Did Not

On the night of January 24, 2023, Lindsay Clancy sent her husband Patrick out of their Duxbury home for takeout and medication, then used exercise resistance bands to strangle five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson and eight-month-old Callan in the basement before attempting suicide by cutting her wrists and neck and jumping from a second-story window. She has never disputed that sequence. What she and her defense have claimed, and what eleven of the twelve jurors in the 2026 trial ultimately accepted, is that she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis so severe that a male voice was commanding her to kill the children and then herself, leaving her unable to appreciate the wrongfulness of her conduct or to control her actions under Mᴀssachusetts’ lack-of-criminal-responsibility standard. Defense experts testified that she was also dealing with bipolar disorder and heavy medication that compounded the psychosis, and that the combination produced command auditory hallucinations consistent with a complete break from reality. The first trial, which ran nearly six weeks and featured more than eighty witnesses, became a battle between those experts and prosecution experts who argued the sequence showed planning, awareness and rational decision-making. 

Prosecutors described the killings as “intentional, rational and swift,” pointing to the decision to isolate herself with the children, the choice of a quiet method, and the subsequent suicide attempt as evidence that she understood the consequences. They maintained that even if she was depressed or struggling after the birth of Callan, she still knew right from wrong and deliberately carried out the acts. Jurors heard from Patrick Clancy, from neighbors, from medical providers who had treated her, from friends, and from the competing psychiatrists. Deliberations stretched past thirty-eight hours over seven days. The foreperson’s notes indicated that eleven jurors were prepared to find her not guilty by reason of lack of criminal responsibility while one juror, Michael Desronvil, refused. Desronvil later told interviewers he saw the actions as methodical and had no reasonable doubts; other jurors claimed he acknowledged doubt yet would not apply the standard as instructed by Judge William Sullivan. 

That split is now the foundation of the March 29, 2027, retrial that Sullivan set on November 16, 2026. Prosecutors signaled they will again pursue first-degree murder charges by stating the case “requires a jury trial,” and Reddington responded that “the die has been cast,” ruling out any plea and suggesting the defense may have an advantage because of the prior 11-1 vote. He has indicated he will present some different witnesses while keeping the core psychosis defense intact. Sullivan denied the defense motion to dismiss on double-jeopardy grounds, finding manifest necessity in the hung jury, and also refused further investigation of the holdout juror; an appeal of those rulings is headed to the Supreme Judicial Court. Clancy remains at Tewksbury Hospital, still paralyzed from the chest down from the 2023 jump. 

The medical testimony will again be central. Defense experts will revisit the postpartum period after Callan’s birth, the rapid onset of severe symptoms, the medications she was taking, and the specific claim of a commanding male voice. Prosecution experts will again emphasize the planning elements and argue that the hallucinations, if they existed, did not negate criminal responsibility. The first jury’s near-unanimous acceptance of the defense theory is expected to color voir dire, with both sides trying to seat jurors who will view the same expert clash differently. Reddington has said the family remains supportive even though Clancy’s condition is not good and she has continued to struggle with suicidal ideation. Patrick Clancy has publicly described returning home to the scene, holding the dying infant Callan, and has spoken of forgiveness while also filing a civil suit against the providers who treated Lindsay. 

What the retrial will test is whether a new jury, knowing that eleven people already found the mental-illness evidence compelling, will reach a different result or the same ᴅᴇᴀᴅlock. The case has already forced a national conversation about postpartum psychosis, the adequacy of maternal mental-health care, and the difficulty of applying the legal standard of lack of criminal responsibility when the defendant admits the acts but claims she was not in control. With the March 2027 date locked in and the appeal pending, the same core facts, the same competing experts, and the same single-juror mystery will be presented again, only this time with the knowledge of how close the first jury came to acquittal. The voice Clancy says she heard remains the central contested fact, and twelve new jurors will have to decide whether it was real enough to erase criminal responsibility.