‘Toxic’ fears behind Steelers’ decision to trade George Pickens to Cowboys

‘Toxic’ fears behind Steelers’ decision to trade George Pickens to Cowboys

It seems some of George Pickens’ now-former Steelers teammates couldn’t wait to say “good riddance.”

Days after Pittsburgh traded the mercurial wide receiver to the Cowboys, Steelers beat reporter Mark Kaboly alleged Monday that “significant locker room guys got fed up with Pickens’ antics” and feared toxicity could spread.

“Some felt that it would be counterproductive to keep him around, even with his unique talent,” Kaboly posted in a lengthy message on X. “They felt the locker room could turn toxic.”

A new report claims “significant locker room guys got fed up” with George Pickens’ “antics” before he was traded to the Cowboys in May 2025. Getty Images
The report also suggested, “Some felt that it would be counterproductive to keep him around.” Getty Images

A second-round pick out of Georgia in 2022, Pickens found himself at the center of controversy last season because of his behavior, whether arriving late to contests or drawing unsportsmanlike conduct penalties during crucial games.

Head coach Mike Tomlin implored the 24-year-old Pickens to “grow up” after being flagged in a December game against the Bengals.

Pickens’ future in Pittsburgh became a prominent storyline this offseason, with eagle-eyed fans pointing out this spring how he stopped following the team on social media.

The Cowboys traded a 2026 third rounder and a 2027 fifth rounder for George Pickens. Getty Images

Even when the Steelers reportedly put Pickens on the trading block last month during the 2025 NFL Draft, some opposing teams “laughed at the idea of inviting Pickens into their locker room for any price, let alone a second-day draft pick,” according to The Athletic.

That lack of enthusiasm around Pickens aligns with Kaboly’s reporting, who noted Monday, “Not many teams were interested in trading for Pickens, making it difficult for the Steelers to get market value,” and how the club “wouldn’t have traded him for anything less than a 3rd-round pick — something that wasn’t offered until after the draft.”

That allowed Dallas to pick up a shiny new toy for quarterback Dak Prescott last week for the price of a 2026 third-round pick and a 2027 fifth-rounder. The Steelers also shipped a 2027 sixth-rounder to the Cowboys as part of the deal.

George Pickens will be catching pᴀsses from Cowboys QB Dak Prescott (4) this season. Bill Kostroun/New York Post

Although Pickens has embraced his new surroundings — “I like the mojo here. I like the swag,” — drama has followed.

On Sunday, Pickens denied ripping the Steelers after purported screensH๏τs seemingly showed he did just the opposite.

“Stop with the AI trying to make a story,” Pickens wrote in an Instagram Story. “I’m happy for everything that the steel city did for me.”

Pickens will make his regular-season debut with his new team on Thursday, Sept. 4, when the Cowboys open the season against the reigning Super Bowl champion Eagles.

Related Posts

Chiefs bring in ex-crime boss to inspire Travis Kelce, Patrick Mahomes and Co during NFL training camp

Chiefs bring in ex-crime boss to inspire Travis Kelce, Patrick Mahomes and Co during NFL training camp

The Kansas City Chiefs were treated to a motivational talk from a reformed crime boss, who then sat alongside Travis Kelce and Patrick Mahomes for a watch party…

Aaron Rodgers opens up on his ‘incredible’ new wife as NFL legend discusses secret wedding

Aaron Rodgers opens up on his ‘incredible’ new wife as NFL legend discusses secret wedding

Aaron Rodgers has paid a touching tribute to his mystery wife and revealed how their secret wedding has given him the belief that he can do ‘anything’….

NFL first-round draft pick Treylon Burks fractures collar bone in crushing blow to Tennessee тιтans

NFL first-round draft pick Treylon Burks fractures collar bone in crushing blow to Tennessee тιтans

The Tennessee тιтans have been hit with a disappointing setback with wide receiver Treylon Burks reportedly breaking his collar bone in practice. The 25-year-old Burks, a first-round…

Travis Kelce’s friend predicts stunning Chiefs trade that will see him ditch NFL retirement plans

Travis Kelce’s friend predicts stunning Chiefs trade that will see him ditch NFL retirement plans

Travis Kelce’s sports analyst friend Nick Wright has theorized that there could be one player to convince the Kansas City Chiefs star to play one more season…

Shedeur Sanders endures new NFL humiliation at Cleveland Browns camp, months after shock Draft slide

Shedeur Sanders endures new NFL humiliation at Cleveland Browns camp, months after shock Draft slide

If Shedeur Sanders is going to fulfil his dream of becoming a starting NFL quarterback at the Cleveland Browns, he is going to do it the hard…

Travis Kelce leaves fans baffled with his latest endorsement: ‘Most random crossover’

Travis Kelce leaves fans baffled with his latest endorsement: ‘Most random crossover’

Travis Kelce has left fans stunned with his latest partnership after the NFL star teamed up with one of the internet’s most popular online games.  The Kansas…