Allowing Joe Schoen to chase Matthew Stafford is as reckless as it is desperate for the Giants

Allowing Joe Schoen to chase Matthew Stafford is as reckless as it is desperate for the Giants

Ultimately, ownership is to blame. Because it is allowing Joe Schoen to remain the Giants general manager, searching for a quick fix when no such elixir exists for a team that won three of 17 games this past season.

“It’d better not take too long because I’ve just about run out of patience,” co-owner John Mara said last month. “I’m going to have to be in a better mood this time next year than I am right now.”

Of course Schoen is going to search for a shortcut, to try and acquire the best quarterback available. Of course he would prioritize the present over the future, to squeeze out as many wins as possible in 2025 — even if the playoffs remain a pipe dream — and strengthen his case for 2026, postponing the possibility that he never sits in such a chair again. Of course he is going to attempt a Hail Mary on his final play.

But only under the influence of desperation would acquiring Matthew Stafford make sense for the Giants. Only then could Schoen — who met with the quarterback’s representatives this week — imagine the 37-year-old helping solve the team’s many problems, excelling behind a broken offensive line and without an indoor home field for the first time in his career, while erasing the mistakes of a bottom-10 defense. Only then could you envision the Giants rising in a division featuring the Super Bowl champions (Philadelphia), its NFC Championship Game opponent (Washington) and Dallas, which won 12 games in three straight seasons before Dak Prescott’s 2024 campaign was limited to eight appearances.

Related Posts

Abdul Carter feels ‘good’ about his new number after selection drama

Abdul Carter feels ‘good’ about his new number after selection drama

On the first day, Abdul Carter wore jersey No. 51. Not 56. Not 11. Those numbers remain retired for Lawrence Taylor and Phil Simms, respectively. “I feel…

Cleveland Browns coach Kevin Stefanski squirms when asked about Shedeur Sanders

Cleveland Browns coach Kevin Stefanski squirms when asked about Shedeur Sanders

Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski attempted to play down the importance of Dillon Gabriel taking the first reps at rookie minicamp – ahead of Shedeur Sanders at rookie…

Jaxson Dart continues to pᴀss Giants tests as he awaits more

Jaxson Dart continues to pᴀss Giants tests as he awaits more

It does not take long to sense that Jaxson Dart is comfortable with himself, around his teammates — even those he just met — in interview settings…

Arian Smith ready to put drops issue behind him and add new dimension to Jets

Arian Smith ready to put drops issue behind him and add new dimension to Jets

Jets rookie wide receiver Arian Smith has heard the talk. The pre-draft evaluations of Smith all talked about how he had world-class speed, but dropped too many…

Atlanta Falcons make decision on future of quarterback Kirk Cousins

Atlanta Falcons make decision on future of quarterback Kirk Cousins

Kirk Cousins looks set to start the 2025 NFL season as backup quarterback for the Atlanta Falcons, according to reports. But the 36-year-old’s wealth of experience means…

John Elway’s agent Jeff Sperbeck’s cause of death revealed

John Elway’s agent Jeff Sperbeck’s cause of death revealed

Jeff Sperbeck, the longtime agent and close friend of NFL legend John Elway, died in what California investigators are calling an accident. The Riverside Sheriff’s Coroner has…