Heritage or unethical exploitation? Mummy exhibit sparks debate in Mexico

Detail of a mummy at the Sangre de Cristo Museum in Guanajuato, Mexico, June 6, 2023. (AFP PH๏τo)
Detail of a mummy at the Sangre de Cristo Museum in Guanajuato, Mexico, June 6, 2023. (AFP PH๏τo)

Controversy has been sparked in Mexico as visitors gather to observe and contemplate the mummified remains of an unidentified woman, affectionately referred to as “the witch,” which are on display at a museum exhibition.

The wizened body – cloaked in a floral blouse and skirt, yellow hair still flowing from her head – is one of more than 100 naturally mummified corpses on show in the central city of Guanajuato.

“I don’t know who decided to display the body in this way, but it has been exhibited like this for many years,” Jesus Borja, Guanajuato’s director of culture, told Agence France-Presse (AFP).

The exhibition has triggered a debate between those who consider the mummies to be part of the city’s cultural heritage and others who see the display as unethical commercial exploitation.

The corpses, which include babies, were exhumed between 1870 and 2004 due to a lack of space in a local cemetery.

Unable to contact relatives of the deceased, local officials designated them as “cultural heritage.”

They are now a very profitable tourist attraction, generating approximately $2 million in annual revenue for the municipality from around 600,000 visitors a year.

The mummies are kept in three museums in Guanajuato, which is known for its colonial architecture as well as its long tunnels and alleyways – remnants of a mining past.

Most of the corpses are exhibited upright in glᴀss cases, with little space between their skulls and the display lights.

A mournful melody plays incessantly in the dimly lit hallways of one of the museums, located in the Santa Paula cemetery.

 

A mummy called
A mummy called “The Witch” is exhibited in a cage at the Dieguino Museum in Guanajuato City, Mexico, June 6, 2023. (AFP PH๏τo)

Ethical debate

The controversy grew after several mummies were transported to the capital Mexico City, located around 350 kilometers (217 miles) by road from Guanajuato, to be shown at a tourist fair in March.

Mexico’s National Insтιтute of Anthropology and History (INAH) has voiced concern about a possible fungal growth on one of the bodies after pictures showed white dots on the torso and legs.

“It’s worrying and strange that an ᴀssessment of such bodies was not made before their transfer,” the public insтιтution said in a statement.

Borja said transportation of the remains was done with due care, adding that the mummies represent a generational “link.”

The Guanajuato government says it asked the INAH to check all the remains before they were exhibited in Mexico City.

The mummy display has divided opinions among residents of Guanajuato.

“I would find it disrespectful if one of my relatives were in the exhibition,” said Luis Garcia, a 50-year-old tour guide.

But Josefina Lemus, a 69-year-old retired teacher, said she would not mind being exhibited if her remains were mummified.

“I don’t think it’s denigrating,” she said, adding, “And it’s unlikely relatives are still around.”

The mummification process can occur naturally as a body becomes dehydrated, said Ilan Leboreiro, an anthropologist who sits on a commission created by the INAH to investigate the idenтιтies and condition of the mummies.

The panel’s goal is also to restore dignity to the remains, added Leboreiro, criticizing the way in which the “witch” is exhibited.

“It’s not ethical to treat the remains of a human being that way,” he said.

Related Posts

Frozen in Time: The Ice Age Cave Lion Cubs of Siberia

Deep beneath the permafrost of Siberia, nature has preserved extraordinary relics of the Ice Age. Among them are the frozen remains of cave lion cubs, small yet…

Whispers of the Desert: The Ancient Mummies of Peru

Hidden beneath the dry sands of Peru’s coastal deserts lie some of the most hauntingly preserved remnants of ancient humanity: the desert mummies. The image of skeletal…

Unearthing Giants: The Mystery of Colossal Skeletons in Human History

Throughout history, tales of giants have captured the imagination of cultures across the globe. From the biblical stories of the Nephilim to Norse legends of towering beings,…

From Neanderthal to Cro-Magnon: The Story of Modern Humanity

The story of human evolution is one of the most fascinating journeys in the history of life on Earth. It is a tale not just of biology…

The Silent Echoes of the тιтanic: A Journey Through Time and Memory

The image of a decayed, water-filled cabin frozen in silence beneath the Atlantic Ocean captures more than just a scene of ruin; it captures history itself. This…

The Discovery of the Polyxena Sarcophagus: Uncovering a Treasure from the Ancient World

A Groundbreaking Find In the summer of 1994, an archaeological team led by Dr. Erhan Özdoğan made a groundbreaking discovery near the ancient city of Troy in…