Sauce Gardner’s OnlyFans tweet lands him, Barstool Sports in defamation lawsuit

Sauce Gardner’s OnlyFans tweet lands him, Barstool Sports in defamation lawsuit

A social media post by one Jets player may have been a little too saucy and is now causing legal issues for himself and one well-known sports media company. 

All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner is being sued by Kalli Mariakis, a 42-year-old mom from Mississippi, for allegedly defaming her during a social media spat where he falsely claimed she had an OnlyFans account. 

The suit, which was filed in New Jersey Superior Court on Dec. 31, also names Barstool Sports as a defendant, according to court documents viewed by The Post. 

Cornerback Sauce Gardner reacts as he walks off the field after the Los Angeles Rams defeated the Jets on Dec. 22, 2024. Bill Kostroun/New York Post

VaynerSports, which represents Gardner, did not immediately reply to a request for comment. 

The lawsuit first came to life after an Ohio law firm blogged about it on Tuesday. 

The lawsuit stems from an August 2024 exchange on X between Gardner and Mariakis, who is described in the suit as an “ardent” fan of the Bills. 

Gardner had posted a pH๏τo of boxes, a ladder and construction equipment and captioned the post, “Do I even have to say what I’m getting built at my new house?” 

That drew a response from Mariakis where she — “jokingly,” per the suit — wrote back to him: “A simulator to teach you how not to commit pᴀss interference or defensive holding?” 

Jets cornerback Sauce Gardner speaks to the media after practice. Bill Kostroun/New York Post

That’s when Gardner replied with the post in question, as he insinuated that Mariakis had an account on OnlyFans, which is a subscription platform primarily ᴀssociated with Sєxually explicit content. 

“I’m sure your husband wouldn’t like it if I told him you [direct messaged] me your OF link would he?” Gardner replied. 

The lawsuit claimed that the social media response by Gardner was viewed by at least 9.5 million people and stated that Mariakis called on the Jets star to provide evidence of his claims in two separate social media replies. 

Sauce Gardner’s since-deleted interaction with a fan on X has landed him in a lawsuit. Sauce Gardner/X

Gardner “or someone acting on his behalf” deleted the post from his X account on Aug. 22, the lawsuit stated. 

The suit denies Mariakas had any such OnlyFans account, accusing Gardner of making a “knowingly false and malicious statement,” while also claiming that it was amplified by a Barstool Sports post тιтled: “If you’re a Married OnlyFans Model Who’s Been DMing Sauce Gardner, You’d Be Wise Not to Troll Him about His Coverage Skill.” 

Mariakis and her family “experienced numerous embarrᴀssing moments and harᴀssment from acquaintances, friends, family, co-workers and the public at large” regarding the Gardner post and Barstool article, the suit claimed. 

Jets cornerback Sauce Gardner takes the field. Charles Wenzelberg/New York Post

It added that people had “cast aspersions on plaintiff and raised questions about her internet activity, especially referencing plaintiff’s alleged — and non-existent — OnlyFans account and, in that connection, questioned her character and reputation as a respectable young-women, wife and mother.” 

The lawsuit is asking for compensatory damages, punitive damages, court costs and fees from both Gardner and Barstool Sports. 

A request for comment from the lawyer representing Mariakis was not immediately returned. 

Gardner’s social media habits have gotten him into trouble before. 

He had to apologize in November over posts in which he fired back at a reporter and a fan following the team’s loss to the Cardinals on Nov. 10. 

At the time Gardner said that he had deleted X from his phone. 

Gardner had 49 tackles, nine pᴀsses defended, one interception and one sack in his third NFL season.

Related Posts

Supercomputer predicts who will make the Super Bowl as Travis Kelce and the Chiefs fight for three-peat

Supercomputer predicts who will make the Super Bowl as Travis Kelce and the Chiefs fight for three-peat

The Kansas City Chiefs are favorites to beat the Philadelphia Eagles in Super Bowl LIX – and complete a historic three-peat.  That is according to data analyzed…

EXCLUSIVEWhat Bill Belichick wants to make shock NFL return weeks after college move amid Tom Brady Raiders links

EXCLUSIVEWhat Bill Belichick wants to make shock NFL return weeks after college move amid Tom Brady Raiders links

Bill Belichick would have to get the ‘biggest coaching deal ever’ to return to the NFL just weeks after becoming UNC’s head coach. Though his contract with North…

Watch as Dolphins teammates learned Tyreek Hill pulled himself out of Jets game

Watch as Dolphins teammates learned Tyreek Hill pulled himself out of Jets game

Tyreek Hill quit on the Dolphins during the third quarter of their loss to the Jets on Sunday, leaving his Miami teammates stunned. The exact moment that…

The major change that helped resurrect Baker Mayfield’s career: ‘Not the way to go about life’

The major change that helped resurrect Baker Mayfield’s career: ‘Not the way to go about life’

Baker Mayfield won’t see your slew of social media insults if he throws an interception on wild-card weekend. The Buccaneers quarterback said Wednesday that he no longer…

Eagle-eyed NFL fans spot the moment Tyreek Hill quit on Dolphins against the Jets

Eagle-eyed NFL fans spot the moment Tyreek Hill quit on Dolphins against the Jets

NFL fans paying close attention to Sunday’s Miami Dolphins’ loss to the New York Jets believe they have pinpointed the exact moment Tyreek Hill quit on his…

Tom Brady’s 5m deal with Fox Sports is over, ex-MLB boss claims in stunning attack on Raiders owner

Tom Brady’s $375m deal with Fox Sports is over, ex-MLB boss claims in stunning attack on Raiders owner

Tom Brady will be running the Las Vegas Raiders full-time next season – and will not return as an analyst on Fox Sports. That’s according to former…