The new burning questions to answer after Giants’ win turned NFL draft order on its head

The new burning questions to answer after Giants’ win turned NFL draft order on its head

One win, so many questions.

The Giants didn’t just snap a franchise record 10-game losing streak Sunday by beating the Colts.

They clarified the playoff picture (eliminating the Colts), shook up the NFL draft order (handing the No. 1 pick to the Patriots for the time being) and gave ownership something to think about next week when deciding the fates of general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll.

Let’s tackle five new questions on the minds of a fan base no longer singularly focused on drafting Colorado’s Shedeur Sanders or Miami’s Cam Ward with the No. 1 pick to be the franchise quarterback.

Where will the Giants draft?

The Giants hold the No. 4 pick and have a smaller than 1-percent chance of regaining No. 1, per ESPN analytics.

So, you’re saying there’s a chance?

Yes, the Giants can get back to No. 1 if they lose to the Eagles (likely playing backups) and three upsets break their way: The Patriots beat the Bills (likely playing backups), тιтans beat the Texans (likely playing backups) and Browns beat the Ravens.

If the Giants lose, they will move up as many spots as there are winners among those other 3-13 teams.

With a win, the Giants could drop as low as No. 9 if the Jaguars, Panthers, Jets, Raiders and Bears — all of whom are Week 18 underdogs — all lose to finish 4-13.

Strength of schedule (.551) works against them in all tiebreakers except maybe versus the Bears (.554).

The Giants have an 88.2 percent chance of a top-five pick.

What did the win do for the job security of Schoen and Daboll?

In theory, one late-season aberration shouldn’t change much of ownership’s big-picture analysis.

It didn’t when Pat Shurmur was fired after a 2-1 finish on the heels of a nine-game losing streak in 2019.

But if the Giants already preferred to keep the status quo, there is now an example to point to of players not quitting on Daboll and what might be possible with him calling plays and getting better quarterback play than happened for most of the season.

Giants coach Brian Daboll’s future is still uncertain. Bill Kostroun/New York Post

Schoen has been operating as if (and spreading the word in league circles that) he expects to be retained.

Co-owner John Mara wore a look of relief to be done with the losing streak as he declined comment to The Post following Sunday’s win.

The counterargument would be that the main justification for keeping Schoen and Daboll before Sunday was that they had not had their chance to draft and develop a quarterback.

But the win might have knocked the Giants out of position to draft their preferred first-round quarterback again, so does that reasoning still hold?

Would decision-makers not on the H๏τ seat make a more honest evaluation of the 2025 quarterback class?

The No. 1 pick — and choice of quarterback — would have been a major selling point to candidates in the event of any job opening(s).

The job is less attractive without it.

What happens to the quarterback search?

The narrowed focus on Sanders and Ward needs to be expanded because those two and receiver/cornerback two-way threat Travis Hunter likely will be drafted top-three in some order.

Start thinking about free agents, led by Sam Darnold and Russell Wilson.

Of course, those two high-end starters could be franchise-tagged or re-signed to extensions by the Vikings and Steelers, respectively.

Kirk Cousins could be a QB option for the Giants. Getty Images

A few recycled bridge options (Andy Dalton, Jameis Winston, Jacoby Brissett) are due to be back on the market.

So is Justin Fields, who drew an unexpectedly weak trade market last season but is still young and had some revitalizing success in six starts for the Steelers.

The Falcons will look to trade the benched Kirk Cousins, whose no-trade clause lets him pick his next destination.

He comes with a $27.5 million guaranteed salary that is reasonable if you believe he can regain his pre-Achilles tear form in his second year of recovery.

Sam Darnold has had a stellar year for the Vikings. Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images

Would the Vikings make 2024 first-round pick J.J. McCarthy — scouted heavily but pᴀssed over by the Giants, who drafted Malik Nabers — available in a trade if they re-sign Darnold?

The Giants also reportedly had their top scouting executives get multiple live exposures to four quarterbacks forecasted to be mid-round picks: Alabama’s Jalen Milroe, Mississippi’s Jaxson Dart, Texas’ Quinn Ewers and Georgia’s Carson Beck.

What would it cost to trade up to No. 1?

The last time that No. 1 was traded was in 2023, when the Panthers sent the Bears No. 9, a future first-rounder, two second-rounders and receiver D.J. Moore to move to the top of the draft.

But Sanders and Ward are not considered in scouting circles to be the same caliber of prospects as Bryce Young and C.J. Stroud were in 2023.

And moving up from around No. 4 instead of No. 9 is a big difference in cost.

Miami’s Cam Ward wll be one of the first QBs taken in the 2025 NFL Draft. Jasen Vinlove-Imagn Images

The two best examples are from two decades ago, though trade returns have skyrocketed since then.

The Chargers traded No. 1 to the Falcons for No. 5, a third-rounder, a future second-rounder and receiver Tim Dwight, while the Giants traded No. 4 (Philip Rivers), a future first-rounder, a third-rounder and a future fifth-rounder to the Chargers for No. 1 (Eli Manning) after the quarterbacks were selected.

Who are the other first-round pick options?

The non-quarterbacks projected to be top-10 picks align well with the Giants’ needs — partly because there are so many spots to upgrade despite 18 of 22 starters being under contract for 2025.

A case could be made for the Giants to look elsewhere for a quarterback now and use their first-round pick on Michigan defensive tackle Mason Graham, Penn State edge rusher Abdul Carter, Michigan cornerback Will Johnson, Texas offensive tackle Kelvin Banks or Arizona receiver Tetairoa McMillan.

Related Posts

Bill Belichick ‘sidelines’ Jordon Hudson after PR disaster in desperate move to salvage reputation

Bill Belichick ‘sidelines’ Jordon Hudson after PR disaster in desperate move to salvage reputation

Bill Belichick is plotting a desperate move to salvage his disastrous publicity crisis as the backlash from girlfriend Jordon Hudson’s excruciating CBS interview interruption continues. Belichick, 73,…

New NFL quarterback resurfaces after team’s brutal benching as he’s spotted at Kentucky Derby week on from draft

New NFL quarterback resurfaces after team’s brutal benching as he’s spotted at Kentucky Derby week on from draft

New Giants draftee Jaxson Dart looked to be in good spirits at the Kentucky Derby on Saturday after learning of his team’s plan to sit him in…

Super Bowl winner A.J. Brown announces life-changing personal news thanks to the help of John Legend

Super Bowl winner A.J. Brown announces life-changing personal news thanks to the help of John Legend

Eagles star A.J. Brown enlisted the help of pop star John Legend to propose to his girlfriend, Kelsey Riley, over the weekend. As shown in a video…

CBS analyst sheds more light on Shedeur Sanders’ ‘very unusual’ atтιтude after NFL Draft freefall

CBS analyst sheds more light on Shedeur Sanders’ ‘very unusual’ atтιтude after NFL Draft freefall

Amid Shedeur Sanders’ NFL Draft freefall, CBS college football analyst Ross Tucker has shed more light on a ‘very unusual’ experience with the former Colorado pᴀsser while…

Shedeur Sanders’ brother responds to Donald Trump after president blasted NFL teams for not drafting him

Shedeur Sanders’ brother responds to Donald Trump after president blasted NFL teams for not drafting him

It’s not often that you see the President of the United States lobbying on behalf of an NFL Draft prospect. Yet, that’s exactly what happened last week….

Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce lose two teammates as Kansas City Chiefs cut down roster

Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce lose two teammates as Kansas City Chiefs cut down roster

The Kansas City Chiefs are making some roster moves in order to sign undrafted free agents. That means some players needed to be cut. Kansas City officially…