đź“– PART 3: THE SECRET THAT COULD DESTROY THEM BOTH

đź“– PART 3: THE SECRET THAT COULD DESTROY THEM BOTH

Rebecca couldn’t breathe.

For several seconds, she simply stared at the document in Charles’s hand.

Then she shook her head.

“No.”

Charles smiled.

“You recognize your signature, don’t you?”

“That’s not possible.”

“Perhaps you should look more carefully.”

He handed the document to Nathan.

Nathan examined it, then pá´€ssed it to Rebecca.

The signature looked remarkably similar to hers.

But Rebecca knew she had never signed a marriage certificate.

She had never stood before a minister.

She had never exchanged vows.

And she certainly had never agreed to become Charles Winters’s wife.

“Where did you get this?” she asked.

“From the county clerk.”

“It’s false.”

Charles sighed theatrically.

“Rebecca, you always were emotional.”

Nathan’s jaw тιԍнтened.

“Careful how you speak to her.”

Charles ignored him.

“My dear, I came all this way to bring you home. You should be grateful.”

Rebecca looked directly at him.

“I would rather spend the rest of my life alone than return with you.”

The words seemed to surprise even her.

Charles’s expression hardened.

“You don’t understand what you’ve done.”

“I understand perfectly.”

“You’ve taken money that belongs to me.”

“No. You stole money that belonged to my father.”

A few ranch hands had gathered outside.

Charles noticed them and lowered his voice.

“You should think carefully before making accusations.”

Rebecca’s fear returned for a moment.

Nathan noticed.

He didn’t touch her or speak for her.

He simply moved aside enough for her to stand where everyone could see her.

Rebecca lifted her chin.

“I have my father’s original business records. I have the bank receipts. And I have the agreement showing that his shares belong to me.”

Charles went pale.

“Give me that notebook.”

“No.”

“Rebecca.”

“No.”

His hand moved toward her.

Nathan stepped forward.

“Don’t.”

Charles withdrew his hand.

Then he gave a short laugh.

“You think this is over? I have witnesses. I have a certificate. I have the law on my side.”

He turned toward the waiting men.

“Ask anyone in Philadelphia. Rebecca Porter and I were engaged. We traveled together. Everyone knew we intended to marry.”

Rebecca answered quietly.

“An engagement isn’t a marriage.”

Charles mounted his horse.

“We’ll settle this in court.”

He rode away without another word.

When the dust finally settled, Rebecca sat on the porch steps.

Nathan brought her a glá´€ss of water.

“Do you want Doc?”

She shook her head.

“I’m all right.”

He sat on the opposite side of the steps.

Neither spoke for a while.

Finally, Rebecca whispered, “He always does this.”

“What?”

“He makes me question what I know. What I remember. What I believe.”

Nathan looked toward the road.

“Then we’ll make sure the truth is written down where he can’t change it.”

That afternoon, Nathan rode to Redemption Springs and brought back Sheriff William Carter.

The sheriff examined the supposed marriage certificate.

He frowned.

“Interesting.”

“What?” Rebecca asked.

“The county seal is genuine. But the clerk’s initials are wrong.”

He examined the paper again.

“And the date is suspicious.”

“Can you prove it’s false?” Nathan asked.

“Not yet. But I know someone who can.”

The sheriff explained that the county clerk, Mr. Elias Turner, was an honest man who kept detailed records of every marriage license.

If Charles had obtained a false certificate, the original application would be missing.

The sheriff promised to investigate.

Meanwhile, Rebecca returned to the ranch office.

She wanted to finish the accounts.

Nathan protested at first, but she insisted.

“I don’t want my entire life to become a courtroom.”

He studied her.

“Then don’t let it.”

She sat down and opened the ledger.

For the next several days, she worked steadily.

Her strength returned little by little. She could walk around the ranch without á´€ssistance, though her ribs still hurt when she moved too quickly.

Samuel became her unofficial á´€ssistant.

He brought her coffee, carried the heavier account books, and occasionally asked questions about arithmetic that made Rebecca laugh.

One afternoon, he entered the office holding a small package.

“Miss Porter, this came by post.”

Rebecca recognized the handwriting on the envelope.

Charles.

Her fingers went cold.

Nathan appeared in the doorway.

“Do you want me to open it?”

She shook her head.

“No. I can do it.”

Inside was a single sheet of paper.

You have until Friday to return the company documents. If you refuse, I will inform the authorities that you stole your father’s money and abandoned your lawful husband.

At the bottom was another sentence.

You have no idea what your father did before he died.

Rebecca read it twice.

Then she opened the notebook and searched through the old entries.

Something had been bothering her.

Her father had never mentioned Charles in his final letters. Yet Charles had somehow known about the inheritance, the shares, and the original business agreements.

There was only one explanation.

He had been watching the family business long before he proposed.

Rebecca found an entry dated nearly four years earlier.

It mentioned a mysterious withdrawal of eight hundred dollars from the company account.

Beside it, her father had written:

Question C.W. about the missing funds. Do not sign any transfer papers until this matter is resolved.

Rebecca’s stomach тιԍнтened.

She turned another page.

There was a second entry.

If I am unable to complete the investigation, the original transfer documents are stored with the bank in Santa Fe.

She looked up.

“There’s more.”

Nathan approached.

“What did you find?”

“My father suspected Charles of stealing from the company before we were even engaged.”

Nathan read the entry.

“Then the marriage certificate may be only part of it.”

Rebecca nodded.

“He didn’t just want to marry me. He wanted my father’s shares because they gave him access to the entire business.”

The following morning, Nathan accompanied Rebecca to the sheriff’s office.

She wanted to make a formal statement.

The sheriff listened carefully, then asked a question that made her heart stop.

“Miss Porter, did your father ever mention a woman named Eleanor Winters?”

Rebecca shook her head.

“Who is she?”

“Charles’s older sister.”

The sheriff opened a drawer and removed an old newspaper clipping.

It reported that Eleanor Winters had died in Philadelphia two years earlier under circumstances that had never been fully explained.

But beneath the article was a handwritten note.

Witness to the missing company funds.

Rebecca looked at the sheriff.

“Why would you have this?”

“Because Eleanor came to my office six months ago. She was traveling through New Mexico and wanted to report something about her brother.”

“Did she?”

The sheriff lowered his eyes.

“She disappeared before she could give her statement.”

Rebecca felt a chill.

Charles had never mentioned that his sister had been in New Mexico.

Nathan studied the clipping.

“Do you know where she went?”

The sheriff shook his head.

“Not exactly. But she sent one letter before she disappeared.”

He reached into another drawer.

The envelope was old and badly worn.

On the front was a name.

Nathan Harding.

Nathan froze.

Rebecca looked at him.

“You knew her?”

He slowly shook his head.

“No.”

The sheriff handed him the envelope.

Nathan opened it.

Inside was a short letter written in a woman’s careful handwriting.

Mr. Harding,

I have been told that you once helped Thomas Porter during his business dealings in the West. I have information that may prove his daughter has been placed in danger. If you receive this letter, please tell Rebecca that her father did not leave her with nothing.

The original records are not where Charles believes them to be.

There is a second set.

And the man who helped Charles conceal the first theft is closer to Rebecca than she knows.

Nathan read the final line aloud.

Do not trust anyone who claims to have come looking for her out of family loyalty.

Rebecca stared at the letter.

“Who helped Charles?”

The sheriff looked toward the window.

“I was hoping you might know.”

Nathan folded the letter carefully.

Then something occurred to him.

Charles had claimed to have witnesses in Philadelphia.

He had arrived in Redemption Springs with a marriage certificate.

He knew Rebecca’s exact location.

And now someone had apparently helped him obtain information about her father’s business.

This wasn’t a simple dispute over an inheritance.

Someone had been arranging things for years.

Before they could discuss it further, the sheriff’s deputy rushed into the office.

“Sheriff! We found something at the telegraph station.”

“What?”

“A message from Philadelphia. It arrived this morning.”

The deputy handed him a folded telegram.

The sheriff read it, then looked at Rebecca.

“Miss Porter, I’m afraid your situation has become more complicated.”

“What does it say?”

He hesitated.

“Charles Winters has reported you missing to the authorities in Pennsylvania. He claims you’re mentally unwell and have been taken against your will.”

Rebecca felt her stomach drop.

“He’s trying to make everyone believe I’m incapable of making my own decisions.”

Nathan looked at her.

“Then we’ll make sure they hear your side.”

But the sheriff wasn’t finished.

“There is something else. The telegram mentions another person traveling here.”

“Who?”

The sheriff turned the paper around.

Rebecca recognized the name immediately.

Her father’s former business manager.

Mr. Edward Bell.

The man who had taught her bookkeeping.

The man who had attended her father’s funeral.

The man who had told her that Charles was a trustworthy gentleman.

And the man who had signed as a witness on her supposed marriage certificate.

Rebecca slowly lowered herself into the chair.

For months, she had believed Charles was the only person who had betrayed her.

Now she understood that the man who had helped destroy her family might have been standing beside her all along.

Outside, Nathan’s horse suddenly began making a loud commotion.

Samuel rushed through the door.

“Nathan! There’s a rider coming up the road!”

“Who?”

Samuel looked toward Rebecca.

“He says he’s Edward Bell.”

Nathan stood.

Rebecca’s hands trembled, but she rose too.

This time, she wasn’t going to hide in a bedroom or wait for someone else to speak.

She walked toward the door.

Nathan moved beside her.

“Are you ready?”

Rebecca took a deep breath.

“No,” she answered honestly.

Then she lifted her chin.

“But I’m going anyway.”

When the front door opened, a familiar elderly gentleman stood on the porch.

His expression was warm.

His voice was gentle.

“Rebecca, my dear. Thank heaven I’ve found you.”

For one brief second, Rebecca almost believed him.

Then she noticed what he was holding.

A small leather case.

The same case her father had kept locked in his office.

And attached to its handle was a brá´€ss key Rebecca recognized immediately.

The key to her father’s missing records.

Edward Bell smiled.

“Your father left something for you, Rebecca.”

He glanced at Nathan.

“But I’m afraid you won’t like what it reveals about the man who brought you here.”

Nathan’s expression turned cold.

And for the first time since Rebecca had arrived at Double H, she wondered whether the cowboy who had promised to protect her was about to discover a secret of his own.

TO BE CONTINUED IN PART 4…